Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Capturing the epistemological spirit of what we do: a framework for understanding and developing the professional knowledge of media educators

  • Anglia Ruskin University

Research output: Contribution to conference › presentation › peer-review

5 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Recent work in media education (Thomason, 2025; Connolly 2025) has refocused attention on the role of knowledge in media studies and its cognate subjects, suggesting that dominant conceptions of knowledge - particularly those emerging from education policy discourse and academic research in education - do not adequately represent how knowledge functions in this field. As the authors have argued, the forms of knowledge that media teachers draw on are diverse, cross-pollinating, inherently fluid and situated within a rapidly evolving contemporary digital and cultural landscape. Thomason’s notion of the “dynamic episteme” and Connolly’s articulation of a “techne pedagogy” offer new language for understanding the multiple domains and complex terrain that media educators must navigate - an interrelated web of technological knowledge, critical knowledge, creative inclination, technical skills, pedagogical approaches and theoretical knowledge. In light of this recognition, and in response to increasing policy emphasis on media literacy and a resulting imperative to train more media educators (UK Parliament, 2025), we argue that the development of a coherent and ‘epistemically-authentic’ subject-specific model of professional knowledge is both timely and essential. Drawing on interview data gathered from interviews with over 30 teachers across a wide range of school and college settings over a 6 year timespan, we aim to establish a model of professional knowledge specific to media teachers. This model is grounded in a broad and - perhaps most crucially - fluid conception of knowledge that acknowledges and incorporates the interplay of technical, pedagogical, and subject-specific dimensions. We propose that this framework is both transferable and reflective of the epistemological spirit that characterizes media educators - capturing what they know, how they feel, and what they are able to do in their everyday practice. Whilst teacher knowledge is well researched and theorized in other curricular areas such as English (e.g. Doecke et al, 2007; Yandell, 2017) and History (e.g. Chapman, 2021), the same cannot be said for media education. Where models do exist, they often focus on the practicalities of the classroom or media content, (Buckingham, 2003; McDougall, 2006;) or give elementary outlines of how initial teacher preparation programs for media teachers might be constituted (Domaille, 2012; Connolly, 2019; Share et al., 2023), with somewhat limited exploration of the deeper epistemological constructions of professional knowledge that media educators engage with. Consequently, there appears to be no comprehensive, unified or systematic model that coherently defines a framework of professional knowledge for media educators exists. In this presentation we attempt to address this lack by offering a more unified holistic account of what media educators know, feel and are able to do. Using empirical data, we connect the knowledge and practices of these professionals to develop a conceptual framework which might be used as a basis for the education and development of media teachers. This framework builds on the ‘considerations of professional identity’ (Thomason, ibid), the conceptual terrain of techne pedagogy (Connolly, 2025) and the “broad areas of knowledge and skill” (Connolly, 2019; p.4) required by media educators. It seeks to shift focus from who media educators are to what they know, how they teach, and how their knowledge is enacted in practice. It does this by identifying six interdependent dimensions (Curricular Imagination, Intermedial and Cultural Literacies, Pedagogy and Assessment for Criticality, Production Based Pedagogy, Ethical and Inclusive Media Teaching and Subject identity, agency and advocacy) of professional knowledge that media educators draw on in their practice - sometimes consciously, sometimes instinctively - while navigating a subject that is always in motion. These dimensions are not fixed categories, nor separate silos, but porous and cross-generative strands of professional knowledge that are constantly reshaped in relation to curriculum reform, student experience, institutional pressures, and shifting cultural contexts. Taken together, they offer a kind of conceptual architecture for articulating the distinctive intellectual, pedagogical and dynamic work that media educators undertake. As established by Thomason and Connolly’s previous work, media education and media literacy are not subjects that fit neatly into traditional disciplinary moulds; its boundaries are fluid, its knowledge base hybrid, and its legitimacy often questioned. Marginalized in curriculum hierarchies and overlooked in policy discourse, media education has always carried a subversive charge – a quality that many of its teachers hold as part of their professional identity. To teach media is not just to deliver content, but also be allied to cultural analysis and critique, creative expression, and intellectual resistance The framework also acknowledges the unique relationship media education has with popular culture and the need for teachers to therefore draw on a repertoire of professional knowledge that includes cultural intuition, intertextual insight, and the capacity to translate and scaffold student expertise into rigorous, critically informed learning. The result is a kind of boundary-crossing professionalism that resists traditional binaries between knowledge and skill, theory and practice, teacher and student (Andrews & McDougall, 2012) We propose that this model may support both novice and experienced practitioners in articulating, expanding, and defending their practice, alongside helping teacher educators to develop curricula which adequately prepare new media educators. Our aim is not to fix the knowledge of media educators into a rigid taxonomy, but to offer a flexible and transferable conceptual tool that can support further dialogue about what professional knowledge in media education entails and to offer the subject discipline a unifying, coherent language to strengthen their understanding of the subject and its greater pedagogical purpose within the wider project of education. In this regard, how media educators develop and enact their expertise is key, not only for supporting teachers, but also for sustaining the subject itself and its corollary of performing a vital democratic and civic function. References Andrews, B., and McDougall, J. (2012). ‘Curation pedagogy: Further toward the inexpert’, Medijkske Studije, 3(6), pp. 152–67 Buckingham, D. (2003). Media Education: Literacy, learning and contemporary culture. Cambridge: Polity Press. Chapman, A. (2021) Knowing History in Schools: Powerful knowledge and the powers of knowledge. London: UCL Press Connolly, S. (2022). Critical Media Literacies in Teacher Education. In: Peters, M.A. (eds) Encyclopedia of Teacher Education. Springer, Singapore. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-16-8679-5_234: 4–12. Connolly, S. (2025) Knowledge and Knowing in Media and Film Studies. UCL Press Doecke, B., B. Green, A. Kostogris, J.-A. Reid, and W. Sawyer. 2007. “Knowing Practice in English Teaching? Research Challenges in Representing the Professional Practice of English Teachers.” English Teaching: Practice and Critique 6 (3) Domaille, K. (2012). “The professional preparation, progression and development of media teachers” in Scarratt, E., & Davison, J. (Eds.). The Media Teacher's Handbook (1st ed.). Routledge. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203222218 McDougall, J. (2006). The Media Teacher’s Book. London: Hodder Arnold. Share, J., Mamikonyan, T., & Lopez, E. (2023). Critical Media Literacy in Teacher Education, Theory, and Practice. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Education. Retrieved 12 Sep. 2025, from https://oxfordre.com/education/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780190264093.001.0001/acrefore-9780190264093-e-1404. Thomason, M. (2025). ‘A site of conflict and resistance: The impact of the 2014 curriculum reforms on A Level media studies’. EdD thesis, Bournemouth University. UK Parliament (2025) House of Lords Communications and Digital Select Committee into Media Literacy, available online at https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld5901/ldselect/ldcomm/163/163.pdf Yandell, J (2017) Knowledge, English and the formation of teachers, Pedagogy, Culture & Society, 25:4, 583-599, DOI: 10.1080/14681366.2017.1312494
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 6 Jun 2026
EventInternational Media Literacy Research Symposium - John Cabot University, Rome, Italy
Duration: 3 Jun 2026 → 6 Jun 2026
https://www.imlrs.net/.

Conference

ConferenceInternational Media Literacy Research Symposium
Abbreviated titleIMLRS
Country/TerritoryItaly
CityRome
Period3/06/26 → 6/06/26
Internet address

UN SDGs

This output contributes to the following UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)

  1. SDG 4 - Quality Education
    SDG 4 Quality Education

Keywords

  • media literacy
  • knowledge
  • media studies
  • teachers
  • Curriculum

Cite this